The use of Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness in the great books canon creates two polar impulses: canons stink and greatness overcomes limitations. The novella does some interesting work, but as Chinua Achebe has pointed out in “An Image of Africa,” published in Hopes and Impediments, the work remains clouded in the painful colonial enterprise and concludes that Conrad is “a bloody racist.” In this way, the great books program forces us to read a text that for practical purposes has moved away from a critique of colonialism to the condemnation of Conrad’s inherited racism. If any text in the great books canon reveals how arbitrary canons can be, it is this one. In a post-colonial world, would we be better off to let this one piece of literature disappear?
Given that students encounter this text at the end of their curriculum, I am convinced that they are capable of understanding the flaws, racism and paternalism, present in the novella. Remembering Achebe’s critique to read carefully, Conrad’s context matters for understanding the piece. And on this score, I am more than grateful for the great books pedagogy, which allows us to escape the long history of how the text has been read in a post-colonial world. In this way, Conrad’s reshaping and ambiguous use of light and darkness reveals as much about how he saw the colonial enterprise once he lived it. We are often capable of dealing with life in the abstract but abandon the principle in the contact with reality. As Dostoevsky’s Ivan notes, we can like humanity in general while still despising individuals in particular. The idea of bringing civilization (light) to the uncivilized (the dark continent) found ample expression in European and American intellectual and missionary life. Evil resides in the “Other” in this framework.
Here is where Conrad’s work reveals how uncomfortable he had come to see the work of Christianizing the “dark” places on earth. The near universal rejection of Heart by English audiences reveals the power of his indictment. Although the Belgium Congo was the target of the novella, England’s own role, and by extension Europe, in “subduing” the earth showed how easy it was to believe in the effort of “improving” a group of people. In this way, the text reminds us that we may play a role in harming others while trying to make them better. At the end of a curriculum where progress and enlightenment appear to be the trajectory of learning, Heart of Darkness fits comfortably as a reminder of how wrong we can be. The true benefit of the canon will be realized when we heed Achebe’s warning that Conrad should be read with a dampened enthusiasm, and alongside Things Fall Apart.